At the 2019 Asembia Specialty Pharmacy Summit, Cardinal Health’s Bruce Feinberg articulates the pros and cons of copay accumulator programs.
Bruce A. Feinberg
Just a few weeks ago, CMS finalized a new rule in its 2020 Payment Notice permitting payer organizations to implement copay accumulator programs, which will no longer count any manner of manufacturer discounts towards a patient’s healthcare deductible.
While CMS argues this ruling will help encourage patients to use less-expensive generic drugs when available, the decision flies in the face of states like Virginia and West Virginia, which have recently passed legislation banning such programs, citing patient protection concerns.
The idea of copay accumulation is simple. Under such a program, health plans no longer need count copay assistance programs, copay cards, manufacturer coupons, or other copay assistance that patients may use to help them afford brand name medications toward a patient’s deductible.
With so many pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs) assigning specialty drugs to the highest copayment tier, some, like CMS, argue that copay accumulator programs will help inspire patients to use lower costing drugs.
Others hold that they will result in skyrocketing out-of-pocket costs for patients, particularly patients who are living with chronic medical conditions-as well as limiting access to patients using the most medically appropriate medications. Bruce A. Feinberg, vice president and chief medical officer at Cardinal Health Specialty Solutions, led a session at the 2019 Asembia Specialty Pharmacy Summit, in Las Vegas, Nevada, to break down the debate-and help attendees understand the nuances of this ongoing controversy.
Related: How Payers Are Keeping Specialty Drug Costs Down
“Copay accumulator programs have been rapidly deployed in the market, and further adoption is expected in 2019 despite the ongoing debate about their benefits,” he said. “However, their effectiveness has not been demonstrated-and the potential risk to patients if access to some of these therapies is restrict is still unknown.”
Feinberg said that if accumulator programs worked as intended-by persuading providers to write prescriptions for less expensive medicines-payers and PBMs would definitely benefit by not having to cover the greater costs of such brand name drugs. Yet, he stated, the unintended consequences may be that patients are unable to manage the additional financial burdens without those drug manufacturer discounts, leading them to use less-effective drugs, potentially worsening their condition, or discontinuing drug therapies altogether because they can’t afford them.
Copay accumulator programs are gaining in popularity with payer organizations and PBMs-and Feinberg believes we will see wider adoption in the years to come. And while the jury is still out on just what the outcomes of such programs will be, Feinberg stated that healthcare executives should monitor those results carefully, understanding the implications for actual healthcare costs over time and patient access to treatments.
“If these programs result in increased non-adherence rates among patients, it could lead to declining patient outcomes for health systems,” he argued. “The goal of accumulator programs is to increase patient financial responsibility and, in doing so, make patients more accountable and engaged in shared-decision making, choosing more cost-effective treatment options. In theory, this might lower the cost of care if the savings from less costly drugs were passed through to patients and plan members. But it only works if lower cost treatment options exist-and if patients are able to influence their doctor’s prescription decisions.”
Kayt Sukel is a science and health writer based outside Houston.
A Conversation With Greg Baker, RPh, CEO of AffirmedRx
March 31st 2024Greg Baker, CEO of AffirmedRx, describes his early career, shares some of his critical opinions about the pharmacy benefit management (PBM) industry and how, in his view, his company is offering a better alternative.
Read More
David Calabrese of OptumRx Talks New Role, Market Insulin Prices and Other Topics 'On His Mind'
April 13th 2023In this month’s episode of the "What's On Your Mind podcast," Peter Wehrwein, managing editor of MHE connects with the now Chief Clinical Officer of OptumRx Integrated Pharmacies, David Calabrese. In this conversation, David touches on his transition in January as OptumRx’s former chief pharmacy officer and market president of health plans and PBMs to his new role as Chief Clinical Officer where he now focuses more on things such as specialty pharmacy to home delivery — with an overall goal of creating whole-patient care. Throughout the conversation, Calabrese also touched on the market’s hot topic of insulin prices and behavioral health services within the OptumRx community, among other topics.
Listen
Florida Gets the OK. But Will Drug Importation from Canada Actually Happen?
March 5th 2024Canadian health officials warn that maintaining a drug supply for Canadians is their priority. The staunch opposition of the U.S. pharmaceutical industry may also be an obstacle to imports from north of the border.
Read More
Briana Contreras, editor of Managed Healthcare Executive, spoke with Nancy Lurker, CEO and president of EyePoint Pharmaceuticals. Nancy shared a bit about EyePoint and how the organization’s innovative therapies are addressing patient needs through eye care, and most importantly, she addressed C-Suite positions like the CEO role. Nancy shared advice for those seeking to reach the CEO level, especially toward women in healthcare and other roles, and what it takes to run a biopharma company.
Listen
What Payers Need to Know As Retail Pharmacies Move Into Primary Care
September 6th 2023Healthcare beyond the doors of the doctor’s office has the potential to offer more care to more people. But payers need to think about how to ensure that care is consistent. Regardless of the setting, care decisions must be based on evidence-based content and supported with strong patient education.
Read More