News|Videos|November 16, 2026

Helen Colby on how care costs shape the pain patients expect

Author(s)Logan Lutton

Patients facing higher out-of-pocket costs predicted procedures would hurt more than procedures with no copay, according to the results of a recent Carnegie Mellon study.

Patients who expect to pay more out of pocket for a procedure also expect it to hurt more, and that combination may make them less likely to schedule care, according to a series of online experiments from Carnegie Mellon University. The study, “Paying for Pain: How Healthcare Costs Influence Physical Pain Predictions,” was led by Helen Colby, assistant teaching professor of marketing at the Tepper School of Business at Carnegie Mellon University.

The research builds on the pain of paying concept, the idea that spending money causes psychological discomfort. Colby noted that neuroscience research later found that making a payment also activates areas of the brain involved in physical pain. “There is something very visceral about that negative feeling you experience when you have to make a payment,” she said.

The team ran three experiments with more than 1,000 U.S. adults. In the first, participants imagined a blood draw with an out-of-pocket cost of either $53 or $0, and those assigned the $53 cost predicted the draw would be more uncomfortable. The second scenario used an endoscopy procedure, and Colby and her team found that the added pain of paying spilled over into greater financial anxiety and lower willingness to schedule the procedure. The third used a nerve conduction study, a less familiar and more expensive test, and the pattern held. The effect was more pronounced among participants with ongoing financial anxiety, which Colby said likely means some of the most vulnerable patients are the most affected.

The study measured anticipated pain rather than pain experienced in a clinic. Colby said the team focused on predictions because they can shape whether patients decide to seek care at all, and she pointed to a large body of research linking delayed care to less curable disease, higher costs and more emergency room visits.

In this interview with Managed Healthcare Executive, Colby explains the pain of paying concept and walks through the study’s central finding, that a higher expected price raises both anticipated physical pain and financial anxiety while lowering patients’ intent to schedule a procedure.


Related to this article