Health reform provisions must be deemed lawful by the Administrative Procedure Act.
CHECKS ON AUTHORITY
Most PPACA regulations are, or will be, subject to section 553 of the APA, which prescribes the fundamental requirement of "notice and comment" for most "rule-making." Among other requirements, agencies must publish notice of proposed rules and solicit comments before issuing any final rule.
Final rules must generally be published at least 30 days before the rule becomes effective. Regulations violating these procedures are subject to challenge under APA Section 706.
Moreover, any regulation that is arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, unlawful, contrary to constitutional right, or in excess of statutory jurisdiction or authority is subject to challenge in court. Indeed, ensuring that regulations satisfy these core requirements is an important check against agency actions in excess of their authority and will help ensure that PPACA is implemented properly and in accordance with the law.
Recently, the Eternal World Television Network (EWTN) and Legatus filed complaints against the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), the Department of Labor and the Department of the Treasury. These plaintiffs contend that the agencies violated Section 553 of the APA in promulgating regulations to implement PPACA.
The complaints specifically challenge an interim final rule promulgated by HHS, Labor and Treasury, which required all group health plans and insurers offering group or individual plans to provide certain contraceptives, forcing individuals to violate deeply held religious beliefs. In addition to challenging these regulations on constitutional grounds, the plaintiffs' allege the regulations were illegal for violating the APA by failing to provide sufficient prior notice and time for public comment.
Other similar challenges are likely to follow. Given the outcome of the Supreme Court challenge, the APA now becomes the critical means by which the nature and reach of regulatory actions can be controlled. Thus, the regulations being promulgated to implement PPACA are a fertile battleground for disputes on how the United States' healthcare system should actually function on a day-to-day basis.
The cases discussed above are the beginning of what is very likely to be an extended struggle.
This column is written for informational purposes only and should not be construed as legal advice.
Phillip R. Seckman is a partner with McKenna Long & Aldridge LLP.
Amy Siadak is an associate with McKenna Long & Aldridge LLP.
35th World AIDS Day Marks 20 Years of PEPFAR: Challenges and Strategies to Combat HIV/AIDS
November 29th 2023PEPFAR, having invested $100 billion and saved 25 million lives in the global fight against HIV/AIDS, faces Congressional hurdles in its reauthorization due to abortion debates. Despite widespread support and no evidence of abortion-related activities, the legislative process is at a standstill. Members of PEPFAR and authors of a recent editorial stress the significance of PEPFAR and advocate for integrating behavioral and social science into healthcare programs to achieve UNAIDS targets and address barriers in HIV/AIDS testing and treatment.
Read More
Bridging the Diversity Gap in Rare Disease Clinical Trials with Harsha Rajasimha of IndoUSrare
November 8th 2023Briana Contreras, an editor with Managed Healthcare Executive, spoke with Harsha Rajasimha, MD, founder and executive chairman of IndoUSrare, in this month's episode of Tuning in to the C-Suite podcast. The conversation was about how the disparity in diversity and ethnicity in rare disease clinical trials in the U.S. has led to gaps in understanding diseases and conditions, jeopardizing universal health, and increasing the economic burden of healthcare.
Listen
Managing Editor of Managed Healthcare Executive, Peter Wehrwein, had a discussion with William Shrank, M.D., a venture partner with Andreessen Horowitz, a venture capital firm in Menlo Park, California, about how artificial intelligence's role is improving healthcare, where we are today with value-based care and the ongoing efforts of reducing waste in the healthcare space for this episode of the "What's on Your Mind" podcast series.
Listen