President George W. Bush began his second term by launching a high-profile campaign to limit skyrocketing medical malpractice insurance premiums for physicians and hospitals.
President George W. Bush began his second term by launching a high-profile campaign to limit skyrocketing medical malpractice insurance premiums for physicians and hospitals. He claims that tort reform will curb healthcare expenses by reducing junk lawsuits and excessive jury awards. Physicians and medical specialty groups are leading the Republican-backed effort, which also would benefit hospitals, insurers, health plans and drug makers. Their powerful argument is that many obstetricians and surgeons can't afford the insurance needed to stay in practice.
Defenders of the current system-namely trial lawyers and patient advocates-counter that the GOP tort reform plan will not really lower healthcare spending and would prevent seriously injured patients from obtaining fair settlements. Low-income plaintiffs would lose the most from a low cap on punitive damages because their economic losses would not warrant sufficient compensation. Many analysts attribute rising insurance premiums more to insurance industry consolidation, underwriting cycle fluctuations and reduced insurance company income from investments-and not to astronomical legal settlements.
CAPPING DAMAGES The House approved broad malpractice reform legislation last year, but Democrats blocked similar action in the Senate. The administration and others have proposed a range of reforms to limit unwarranted lawsuits against healthcare providers while allowing patients suffering harm to receive appropriate awards:
While there is fairly broad support for curbs on class-action suits and other procedural reforms, a stiff fight is brewing over the $250,000 cap on damages. But if compromise is in the air, Congress and the White House could get together on a bill that sets some limits on liability suits while also supporting changes likely to reduce malpractice in the first place.
In this episode of the "Meet the Board" podcast series, Briana Contreras, Managed Healthcare Executive editor, speaks with Ateev Mehrotra, a member of the MHE editorial advisory board and a professor of healthcare policy and medicine at Harvard Medical School. Mehtrotra is also a hospitalist at the Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center in Boston. In the discussion, Contreras gets to know Mehrotra more on a personal level and picks his brain on some of his research interests including telehealth, alternative payment models and price transparency.
Listen
Inflation Reduction Act: Reforms to Patient Cost-Sharing
September 18th 2023Lower out-of-pocket costs for patients might put upward pressure on drug prices, as manufacturers face less price sensitivity, note Matthew Majewski and Rhett Johnson of Charles River Associates. But they also note that upward pressure on price is likely to be limited to the inflation rate as any additional price increase would need to be paid back to CMS in the form of inflation rebates.
Read More
Spending climbed by 2.7% in 2021. In 2020, it soared by 10.3%, fueled by federal government spending in response to the pandemic. The blizzard of calculations of 2021 healthcare spending by CMS’ actuaries also provides further evidence that utilization of healthcare services bounced back in 2021.
Read More
Talking PIE, the Act, Before Thanksgiving
November 23rd 2022AMCP CEO Susan A. Cantrell spoke with Managed Healthcare Executive® about Preapproval Information Exchange (PIE) Act of 2022, which would allow drug manufacturers to share information about a drug with payers before the drug is approved. Cantrell says passage of the PIE Act would speed up patient access to new medications.
Read More
Inflation Reduction Act and the Impact on Pharmaceutical Pricing and Investment Decisions
November 21st 2022The reference to “maximum fair price” in the act bodes poorly for manufacturers and suggests more of a take-it-or-leave-it situation rather than a negotiation where clinical evidence would be the prevailing factor in determining price.
Read More